I did read that entire proposal. Sorry to burst your bubble, but nothing in it is particularly a new “idea”, we have discussed, tested and trialled multiple options for a better “war” system. We have also published everything publicly, so I will be repeating our findings on our few years of playing.

At the most basic level, its not technically possible with what we have now. To implement a factions system, there are 2 options; replace both Claims system and Crew system with a plugin that does both things (Very poorly) that also has some form of war system, or someone (Not me) will have to program a custom plugin to work with our existing plugins.

I sent a rather detailed request to Silence a very long time ago based around a better type of Siege which also implemented crews and crew claims, but I think he lost interest in minecraft all together.

This proposal is a weaker version of an already exiting idea, that we cannot implement with out custom programming, loosely slapped together random ideas.

I could break it down section by section and give tell you my “solution” (There really isn’t a problem in the first place, you are just bored with what we have currently) but there’s no point me going over it all as it wouldn’t be possible anyway without drastic change to the entire servers core structure.

Another idea I have already proposed many, many, many times is a second survival server, with everything in one place, the Wars the No teleport the no map, its nothing new. This type of land factions has always been planned as an alternative to this version of survival but as its own separate survival, I just do not have time to drop PirateCraft to create a second survival server, which would be the proper way to implement everything like this along with all the other major designs people think they want.

TLDR: Learn Java and talk to me about creating a custom plugin.

Please don’t argue via forums. You can do that amongst yourselves, and the whole PirateCraft community does not need to know.

This is nothing new, we actually started PirateCraft over 5 years ago without teleportation and we didn’t grow, its only after enabling it we got a community.

This has litearlyl been disguised to death so I see no reason to repeat myself for the 200th time.

Nothing in here is new, nothing in here hasn’t been though of, we have actually already run as suggested.

The conclusion I came up with will be a second additional server, a whole second survival, as there is so much needed to make this work it would be impossible without starting from scratch.

The second option, which im planning to trial first will be a simple additional extra world (I Stress, this isn’t a trick answer, this means the current wold STAYS NOT A RESET!!) Very important you understand what the word “additional” means, it means its an extra world. Is created with its own permissions, I have maybe trialed 3-4 different types of world variants for this and the idea has matured and changed over the years, it will boil down to:.

Nothing has started as there are so many moving parts and things to do, its never been a good time to drop everything and do it.

Basic overview for those that haven’t read my 1000’s of replies about this topic already.

1. A second additional overworld for this survival server based on islands (NOT STARTED)
2. As its custom generation, I want custom structures to generate with custom items (NOT STARTED)
3. As it will be on this server that world will need its own permissions (NOT STARTED)
4. As it will be on this server, it will need its own re-spawn on death events (IS BROKEN DOES NOT WORK)
5. It will need its own inventory/Echest (Working)
6. Automate resetting the world every X amount of months (Working)

The basis for the “locker” world I already have is to trial and test these features that need to get working, the biggest issue at present is the death event is broken and will just send you back to your bed spawn, I cannot overcome this at present.

A team will be required for point 2, READ the existing forum threads as a build team application is out there, and we have nobody to fill it.

its a process, and it has to be done in order.

-This is more of a direct response to Palmerageddon-

Now Palmer, I can agree that there is some issues with trying to create changes like this while not having much experience on the server.  And there are a few issues to note with the change.  But overall the issues you try to attack I think self-solve themselves fairly easily.

With the issue that you discussed in point 1, the guy who started this thread wasn’t very clear as to what to be removed specifically, so I can see why your concerned that he may be saying to remove all types of hyper-fast transportation (i.e. teleportation, warps, homes).  However, the ideas discussed afterwards cleared this up as people who replied after stated to just delete tps, keep homes, and ill just assume they also want to keep a few of the warps.  This should clear up the issues you discussed in your first statement.

Onto the second point, I think part of my response just above about point 1 cleared this up, as where they die will be their home(s).  As for destroying the point of a place that increases ship usage, this wouldn’t remove the entire purpose of it.  Because if there was lets say a couple warps around spawn, and then everyone got like 1-2-3 homes depending on rank, even if you used all 3 homes you couldn’t get to everywhere on the map effectively and without tp you’d have to use elytras, get a horse, or get a boat, to get to other areas.

Finally, on the last point, I will agree with you on that a lot.  There are people who still use ships from time to time and the person who started this thread could of just sailed around and used his ships more.  Ships are still used on PirateCraft from time to time, and there is of course the official ship battles which take place from time to time.  So yes, he probably could just do that.

Lord Vanther wrote:

You may speak the truth, but one of the main reasons that I chose to follow Reptaria is because she offered something which few other crews did: An officially fantasy-roleplaying crew, where there was a purely different feeling. We created our own history, our own laws, and actually felt like a nation, not a loose amalgamation of players with no real goals or ideals.

Great reply, a lot of people didn’t get the role play aspect, I hope you are able to bring this back to PirateCraft.

It’s been one year since your ban, I will grant you another chance, LAST chance since nothing besides that ban shows up on your punishment checker, don’t mess it up again.

And welcome back to piratecraft

This is awesome XD enable PvP in there too so that the people need to work together or they are getting nowhere.

Also, maybe make some smol sand crabs. Idk, just like the movies (heh). And maybe, if this project keeps going and being updated, a Black Pearl that brings you back to piratecraft cove.

😀

I wouldn’t call it taking sides, im just pointing out how you are incredubly toxic and use a large amount of Derogatory terms on Piratecraft, you have a total of 4  bans, 11 mutes with 8 related to toxicity and then 10 warnings (6 for racist comments). If anything im amazed you have not been banned yet or even just realised that how you act is so wrong.

Ic3y ;] wrote:

He is an utter moron who got upset so he did the most childish thing imaginable.

yeh your on here first of all posting a video of 1v1ing orange randomly just because he reported you in a block game, then trying to say i suck at 1.12 because i agreed that you have broken a large amount of the server rules. not to mention calling orange a “Retard” and other rude remarks in game over said report

Edit: Orange didnt do anything childish in all honesty, he saw you broke a rule so he followed exactly what the server and anyone would say to do and report it on the forums