Siegable Blocks

Home Forums Server Support Requests & Suggestions Siegable Blocks

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 35 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #43385
    Smokey River
    Moderator
    • Topics: 22
    • Replies: 269
    • Total: 291
    • ★★★★★

    Alright everyone I need player input on this. We are talking about adding more blocks to the siegeable list! Let me know what you think should be added so I can compile a list!

    Thanks

    Smokey

    Here is a list of the current siegeable blocks;
    – DIRT
    – GRASS
    – LONG_GRASS
    – COBBLESTONE
    – GRAVEL
    – SAND
    – GLASS
    – THIN_GLASS
    – WOOD
    – WOOL
    – SNOW
    – STAINED_GLASS
    – STAINED_GLASS_PANE
    – WOOD_DOUBLE_STEP
    – WOOD_STEP
    – NETHERRACK

     

     

    UPDATE OF SUGGESTIONS:
    *if i missed any let me know I will add it*

    All Plants (includes flowers and crops)
    Bone Block
    Bookshelfs
    Cake
    Carpets
    Coarse dirt
    Cobblestone slabs
    Cobblestone stairs
    Cobblestone wall (both types)
    Crafting Tables
    Cracked Stone Brick
    Double cobblestone slabs
    Double Wood Slab
    End Stone
    Hay Bales
    Ice (Not Packed)
    Jack-o-lantern
    Leaves
    Melon block
    Mossy cobblestone
    Mushroom
    Mushroom blocks
    Mycelium
    Netherwart block
    Path Block
    Podzol
    Pumpkin block
    Snow
    Sponge (wet and dry)
    String
    Tilled Farmland
    Torch
    Vines
    Wood Stairs

    ?Smokeyriver?

    I solemnly swear I am up to no good.


    *IF YOU SEE THIS ON YOUR FORUM POST TAKE IT INTO CONSIDERATION*

    -Founder of Crew Savage-
    -Rear Admiral or Super Mod-
    *depends on how you want to view my super powers*

    #43386
    Creepermorderen
    Member
    • Topics: 17
    • Replies: 98
    • Total: 115
    • ★★★★

    Double cobblestone slabs, Mossy cobblestone, coarse dirt, cobblestone wall, melon block, pumpkin block, podzol, bone block. Quick ideas – basically i feel like all the “soft” blocks should be siegeable. 🙂

    #43387
    Artemis
    Member
    • Topics: 11
    • Replies: 59
    • Total: 70
    • ★★★

    Cracked stone bricks, netherwart blocks, stone monster eggs (all varities), path blocks, farmland, string.

    Though a bit extreme, you could also try adding crops to the siegable list.

    ============================================
    YouTuber and proud former member of the Crusaders.
    "Shoot for the sun. Even if you miss,
    it'll finally be quiet around here."
    ============================================

    #43390
    GodsDead
    Keymaster
    • Topics: 794
    • Replies: 3343
    • Total: 4137
    • ★★★★★★★★

     

    #43392
    Redstone_Potato
    Member
    • Topics: 4
    • Replies: 73
    • Total: 77
    • ★★★

    Stone Brick.
    I think it’s obvious that was a joke.
    I think cobwebs should be added to the list, as well as soul sand.

    #43394
    Hatter
    Member
    • Topics: 7
    • Replies: 156
    • Total: 163
    • ★★★★

    Hmm… A part of this server’s appeal, in my arrogant opinion, is that it is similar to factions, yet not based on gameplay. The BE would be completely different on a factions server, London would not be a homely, eccentric city, but a practical box.

    I personally would prefer pirate-style domains then unseigable stone brick boxes, but including siegable cobble slabs and other soft blocks might make the latter much more appealing. Soft blocks are great for aesthetics, and to all soft blocks siegable would reduce their viability, in turn reducing the design and creativity on the server.

    Do we want gameplay influenced strongholds, or authentic ports and castles?

    TLDR: Soft blocks make houses look better, Making them siegable makes houses look worse.

    We must, indeed, all hang together or, most assuredly, we shall all hang separately.
    -Benjamin Franklin

    #43396
    Browe_
    Member
    • Topics: 45
    • Replies: 195
    • Total: 240
    • ★★★★

    As a builder I agree its nice to be able to use more block varieties for bases but as a pvper I also want to be able to tear through someones base to kill everything I can poke a sword at! xD

    I think the answer to this is to build yourself a fort and subclaim your base! You can have separate claims for your less defensible structures like towns/docks/farms etc, and if under attack run and hide in your big stone brick fort !

    History:
    ~ Former Admiral in the British Empire ~
    ~ Founder of Phantom ~
    ~ Co-Founder of Templars ~
    ~ Original owner of HMS Sovereign (Phantom Sovereign) ~

    #43399
    Crazy Pirate
    Member
    • Topics: 110
    • Replies: 1997
    • Total: 2107
    • ★★★★★★★

    Double cobblestone slabs, Mossy cobblestone…cobblestone wall, bone block…

    The BE would be completely different on a factions server, London would not be a homely, eccentric city, but a practical box. I personally would prefer pirate-style domains then unseigable stone brick boxes, but including siegable cobble slabs and other soft blocks might make the latter much more appealing

    Basically everything I wanted to say. Double cobble slabs are useful for adding texture, and bone blocks are a good alternative to quartz. Meanwhile, cobblestone walls are also fantastic for windows and window frames.

    I’m thinking sponge, ice (not packed, the normal stuff), snow, end stone, grass (tall and short), vines, and that’s about it.

     

    #43400
    Cysteen
    Member
    • Topics: 13
    • Replies: 434
    • Total: 447
    • ★★★★★

    few things..  for the soft blocks that make houses look nicer, yes, itll make it more difficult, BUT, people need to learn how to protect their homes better. it’s not easy, but possible to re-inforce the siegable blocks with non sieable blocks. most people are just lazy @#$%^&() and build stone boxes.

    a lot of the other blocks would be interesting. netherwart blocks, all dirt variants (mycelium, podzol, tilled farmland, path block , and coarse dirt), vines, leaves [again died a little], maybe even wood stairs? debatable… also for the love of god, tall grass; the grass stalks in a field are the most annoying thing to deal with when pvping.

    also…. can we add crafting tables to the list of siegable blocks?? 😀

    If I had a nickel for every time I, Ooo hey, a butterfly!! *runs off chasing the butterfly*

    - Former Leader of CoV -
    - A Proud Member of The Asylum-

    #43401
    vape
    Moderator
    • Topics: 3
    • Replies: 36
    • Total: 39
    • ★★

    I suggest a long list of items. This includes the following:
    1 Grass
    2 Dirt
    3:1 Coarse Dirt
    3:2 Podzol
    4 Cobblestone
    5,5:1,5:2,5:3,5:4,5:5 all wood planks
    6,6:1,6:2,6:3,6:4,6:5 all saplings
    141,142,59,81,83,86,103,104,105,338 all crops/coco beans
    12,12:1 both types of sand
    13 gravel
    18,18:1,18:2,18:3,161,161:1 all leaves
    102,160-106:15 all glass panes
    30 cobweb
    31,31:1,31:2,32,37,38-38:8,175-175:5,106,111,127 flowers/plants/grass/ferns/vines/lilly pads
    35-35:15 all wool
    163,164,53,134,135,136 wooden stairs
    170 hay bale
    171-171:15 all carpets
    39,40,99,100 mushrooms
    43:2,125-125:5 all double wood slabs
    43:3 double cobblestone slab
    44:2,126-126:5 all wooden slabs
    44:3 cobblestone slab
    47 bookshelf
    48 mossy cobblestone
    50 torch
    58 crafting table
    60 farmland
    67 cobblestone stairs
    78,79,80 snow/ice/snow block
    208 grass path
    216 bone block
    91 jack-o-lantern
    92 cake
    20,95-95:15 all glass blocks
    110 mycelium
    321 painting

    and netherrack

    #43402
    vape
    Moderator
    • Topics: 3
    • Replies: 36
    • Total: 39
    • ★★

    We can have a discussion/tutorial on how to build securely while make a base appeasing to the eye in another forum. I think that would be a great idea. Also, I feel that any resource on the server that is considered rather expensive/not-renewable, such as sponge, beacons, and ores, should stay unbreakable. Everything on my suggested list is easy to get, and easy to replace.

    #43404
    iOdiwanKenobi
    Member
    • Topics: 60
    • Replies: 797
    • Total: 857
    • ★★★★★★

    @ae0, guess who’s rebuilding their shop walls because you said double Cobble slabs could never be sieged? Me! Also I think there should be a 1 month construction period so bases don’t become accessible as soon as the update happens, just my 99 cents

    Ironic

    #43405
    iOdiwanKenobi
    Member
    • Topics: 60
    • Replies: 797
    • Total: 857
    • ★★★★★★

    also for the love of god, tall grass; the grass stalks in a field are the most annoying thing to deal with when pvping. also…. can we add crafting tables to the list of siegable blocks?? ?

    Jesus you’re right, they’re a pain in the *beep*

    Ironic

    #43406
    Cysteen
    Member
    • Topics: 13
    • Replies: 434
    • Total: 447
    • ★★★★★

    I cried when I saw hay bales. I use those to block my chests ;_;

    also with that long list of items, a lot of those are used in decoration, itll suck if someone decides they don’t really wanna get to you, and just wanna @#$%^&*() up your garden, or nuke your house that’s only there to look pretty. *coughshaycough*

    If I had a nickel for every time I, Ooo hey, a butterfly!! *runs off chasing the butterfly*

    - Former Leader of CoV -
    - A Proud Member of The Asylum-

    #43407
    Rivvur
    Member
    • Topics: 20
    • Replies: 163
    • Total: 183
    • ★★★★

    I suggest that all types of dirt should be siegeable.

    Examples: Coarse dirt, Path blocks, podzol.

    (Dirt and grass are obviously already siegeable.)

    Reason: I went to raid noob last night, and all of there chests were covered with coarse dirt. I couldn’t break it (even in siege), which in my opinion is just so stupid.

    I also think that all blocks you can EASILY break with your fists should be siegeable.

    (Even though beacans can be broken with your fist, it obviously shouldn’t be added.)

    Sincerly,

    River

    P.S. Sowwy if I made some spelling errors, made this in a hurry.

    ---------------------

    Proud former leader of The Coalition
    Former member of build team
    ez got banned
    pirate veteran and yeehaw'er

    Crew history:
    BE, DELTA, CREED, SOLIS, TEMPLAR, PHANTOM, EE, TAS, VPS, CLTN, RoP, STRN, ARES, Horse, Mafia, Hope

    "Many of life's failures are people who did not realize how close they were to success when they gave up." -Thomas Edison

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 35 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

/50 Online

Mobile Page

Join the PirateCraft discord server
Join the PirateCraft Discord server! discord.piratemc.com
Reddit - PirateCraft Subreddit PirateCraft YouTube PirateCraft Twitter PirateCraft Instagram PirateCraft Facebook