idk about suicide squads. have to talk to cap about that. but as for maiz, if BE got attacked, and Templars left (even if nobody died) then yes they lose. they tped away, so they ran from the battle. meaning instant loss there. if you tp away from the fight scene, you lose the fight.

i do think the rules need to be clarified a bit more, that will be worked on, (not this current moment as I just woke up 10 minutes ago). ill talk to cap, since he and I were the ones to discuss it before.

also keep in mind that not every single scenario can be described and a rule be made for. that’s just insanity, and while I am insane, I don’t really feel like spending forever thinking of every little scenario and how to award points to a victory. I may have no life and too much time, but that don’t mean I wanna spend it on that. >->

odi, a suicide squad would probably be a horrible idea. id count them under ninjas, since they are still fighting. I mean if someone wants to run into battle with no armor and allow the other side to kill them, more points to them..?

crazy, as long as you didn’t engage in the battle, then you should be able to repot safely. if you get jumped and have to bolt for pots, that’s a 50/50, imo. not everyone is battle ready when building, so idk about that one.

browe, its a whole retreat if they tp away completely. a fight usually never takes place in a small area. it’s all over the place and can span for even a thousand blocks. long as you don’t run like a @#$%& out of the fight, youre still in it.

the siege thing could be debated more, since the siege plugin mechanics kinda have a mind of its own. sometimes it is impossible to siege someone in a box… um.. think about what youre sieging and if you can really win it? it is stated that you need to be brute forced out. not if you walk away because of a box. brute forced means bow spammed, chased out with a sword (or cannon), etc. if you have to walk away from a siege, neither side gets a point, since nothing really happened.

dork,…. too complicated. cannon kill is one point. don’t matter if its an amazing shot, this list isn’t supposed to make this war a competition or a game.

again, this list wasn’t made to be heavily debated over how many points given, or to be turned into a game or competition. it was made to make determining winners of a battle within a war. the more attention we pay to deciding what rule gets what points, the less of a war it becomes and will sound more like a competition. also, you simply cannot list every single scenario or possibility and expect a written rule to be made for it. that makes it way too complicated. id like to think that if something like these scenarios were to happen, then both sides could stop bickering, and agree on something. this war isn’t really a hostile one, and even if it was, theres no need to be barbaric towards eachother in chat over who wins. we aren’t kindergarteners.

odi, this isn’t a class-based Team fight. this isn’t TF2. looks like you hardly took any consideration when typing this, and just gave your own interpretation, instead of a revision. the more in-depth we get with the point system the less of a war it really is and more of a competition it becomes.

the point of this entire thread was to help REDUCE the amount of bickering from everyone about who wins, how any why. now to create a discussion of how in depth we can make this a competition.