I honestly do not think you’re ready to be unbanned. You where warned multiple times by staff, mystic and me have told you many times to calm down on the toxicity or you will be banned. After not listening and not even maturing what so ever I don’t feel like you’re ready to return.  You should’ve taken my advice and waited 6 months like I suggested MULITPLE times. I’m sorry Jelatin, I just don’t think you’re ready to return until further improvement in your behavior.

Jelatin, even though we are friends, I have to be honest here. I don’t think you’re ready yet to be unbanned. You will most likely be given the chance to be unbanned in the future, but you should have waited quite a bit longer before appealing.

I personally haven’t been able to meet you yourself, but the controversy already seen in this post shows that this make take a bit to come to a decision, and from what I’ve experienced in voice chats with you is that you can be annoying, but that’s nothing new on PMC. I hear that you may have been more toxic in the past, but from what I’ve heard you mellowed out a lot more now. Good luck with the appeal!

I remember Jelatin a good bit, though we never really talked a ton, before or after the ban. I would like to give you, from about as knowledgeable an unbiased opinion as I can give.

First, I’d like to say that involving this ban, regardless of anything else, a permanent ban was completely warranted for such inappropriate content. I never actually saw what happened, only heard the stories from other players (including those these….. things were sent to), but I can assure you that it was not pretty in the slightest, even in the stories. With that said, I’d like to go over your tracker, as that + your appeal is all that really matters here (yes, the thing you did was terrible, but the tracker represents that, so…….)

Your ban tracker shows at least 4 blatant cases of intolerance, in addition to 2 mutes (I’m not counting the chargeback bans, as they have no relevance here). You have been muted and banned by multiple staff members on multiple occasions (only this 1 ban), and even when I’d seen you in-game, you never really kept appropriateness as a priority.

Now you are claiming that you’ve changed through your appeal, which has occurred approximately 2 months and 4 days after your ban. To put this into perspective, an xrayer must wait, at bare minimum, at least 3 months (unless I’m mistaken, a first-time occurrence due to lack of knowledge from the rules means 3 months). Personally, I see your crimes being much worse than that, but I did promise to keep this unbiased. With that said, I can assuredly say that other bans similar to yours have lasted anywhere from 1-6 months if they are not permanent (I did a scan over the punishment tracker to find them, I will link some if needed). However, you broke multiple rules, and I believe that with only that in mind, 2 months is nowhere near enough time. However, giving you the benefit of the doubt, I would like to look at your appeal.

You do seem to give a heartfelt appeal, releasing multiple apologies directly to players who you wronged during this. This is certainly a step in the right direction. You also seem to love the use of the word “inappropriate,” and while this is most certainly the right word for what you did, I can’t help but get a sense (as you did cover at the end) of desperateness to be back here. You go over everything you’ve heard about, and I think that the meticulous detail you go into shows either a desperation or a dedication; which of the two, I’m not sure. The appeal itself is well made, and I do believe that this appeal, if any, would bring you back. With that, this side I believe is in your favor.

Now, to wrap everything up, I’d like to briefly remind you that you sound nothing like how you did in-game, as this is something no one else has seen from you before. Again, I haven’t spoken with you after your ban, so I do not know if this is really how you sound or not, but judging from how you were in-game, I honestly fail to see how you could have written such a heartfelt appeal, meaning there is a good chance you really have changed. However, this is a chance ONLY, meaning that it’s also quite possible you haven’t.

Looking at all the evidence, I would recommend changing your ban from permanent to temporary. You do, from your tracker, in-game actions, and appeal, seem to have changed. However, a little over 2 months is nowhere near long enough for something this “inappropriate” to have settled down. Remember back when permanent bans meant you were actually permanently banned? Be thankful you actually have a possibility of coming back.

My final verdict (aka opinion based on the facts): change his ban to a 1-4 month temporary ban so he serves his 6 months at minimum for inappropriateness and harassment and time-wasting of staff. However, keep a close eye on him and ensure this never, NEVER, happens again. Alternatively, reject this appeal and allow another to be made in 1-4 months.

Yeah no. You can wait longer. Unbanning you will bring nothing to the community, i doubt you’ve changed.

Denied and closed