Excellent idea, it just needs to be constantly well-balanced. All players and staff should take part in a consistent balance of potions to make sure they don’t break the game, (pvp or any other form of gameplay). I fully support your idea. +1

Suggestions:

1.) Potion Brainstorm + Balancing

Make two threads, (one for potion ideas, another for potion balancing). Not every potion suggested and implemented is going to be perfect, so some may need to be upgraded or nerfed. This is why it’s essential to have a potion balancing thread for future potions. Balancing would include materials needed, brewing time, potion effects and potion effect duration. If all of these various aspects can be tweaked individually, you can end up making the perfect potions for pvp or otherwise, making a perfect puzzle piece fit in the server’s gameplay mechanics. So balancing is necessary.

This thread can be for brainstorming potion ideas and giving them shape by suggesting materials needed, brewing time, potion effects and duration. After we’ve come up with some potions and they’re implemented in the game, we can test their power levels. If any of them are too OP or too weak, we can discuss boosts and nerfs in a the second thread, the balance thread.

2.) Potion Ideas:

Haste (I and II?) / Strength II + Speed II / Fire Resistance + Absorption / Regen II + Strength II / Water Breathing + Night Vision / Poison II + Instant Damage II (throwing if possible)

————————

I’ll come up with more suggestions as they come to me.

I would something like the “Salty Dog” as just a random brew would interesting. Something as a pvp potion would also be nice maybe oh… I don’t know “Tricksters Soul”??

Potion of fearlessness – extra health, fire resistance, night vision – made from lots of beef and blaze powder

Scurvy splash potion – gives wither effect – made from mob heads and rotten flesh

Seasickness splash potion – nausea and slowness – made from ink sacs and prismarine shards

Pegleg splash potion – slowness and strength – made from wooden fences

Having more splash potions would be awesome in my opinion.

Splash potion of blindness
Splash potion of Nausea

Combined-Hyper-Bunny-Magick Splash potion
Speed II + Jump Boost II 😀

Shark-boy potion
Speed II + Water Breathing

the potion that gives you speed, jump boost and weakness would be cool

also strength 3 with like slowness 1

Will you be using the “WitcherPotions WITCHES BE CRAZY” plugin?

These sound really awesome but these potions really need to be watched because they could get really OP if you throw all these types of potions on you at once. I have a way to stop this and still keep the potions. There could be a Sickness you could catch if you drink to many potions at once, like weakness,slowness,blindness, ect.

some thoughts (regen 2-what ever gapples regen is)

make regen 2, add blaze powder makes idk then add another regen 2 that makes regen 3. Put regen 3 with blaze powder  that makes idk and then add regen 3 again that makes regen 4. Might be a bad idea but what the heck. idk could = some potion called {Harming or what ever.

Also There should be a molitaz Cocktail potion. I don’t know how to spell that but When you through it It could make a 5 by 5 area a fire! Lighting Strike anyone, there could be a potion that sends down lighting on someone.

Oh and Thanks Smokey