Hello everyone,

I’m sorry if this is being repetitively posted however I cannot see it coming up on the forums.. So I will post again.

I had messaged Gods privately to see if this was feasible and my knowledge of the internal workings of mine craft are very slim so I apologize to Gods as I am copying my original DM to him.

As everyone knows and have probably heard ALOT of lately, is that 1.9 killed pvp. As much as I can see the impact on pirate craft I don’t tend to agree. When ever I play minigames on other servers the combat factor has improved. The ability to time attacks, block with a shield and have natural regen makes combat strategic. The days of spam clicking are over and I am really happy about that.
With this being said there are still some flaws. One of the biggest and the reason why I have limited my time on Piratecraft lately is due to the fact that no one dies with Prot 4. In any given battle (1vs1 or 10 vs 1) the ability to eat food run and regen makes it near impossible to kill someone who has good gear. Watch this recent battle posted in forums and see what I mean. (http://piratemc.com/topic/heart-pirates-vs-templar-epic-battle/)
In 1.8, the problem was the OP Gapples. This however was a consequence of staying alive. You had to use a mass amount of resources to stay invincible and even with gapples when armor broke there was still a chance that a player could die. Secon was a prime example of this. He would come into battle with 30 gapples and end up loosing 20 because his armor would break. With the 1.9 combat update the only way to kill someone is by breaking their armor since steak can provide someone in P4 natural regen and allow them to stay alive. This is usually done by spam clicking to wear down durability quicker (back to 1.8). This inability to kill players has not only taken a toll on PVP on the server but I think this is also reflected in the market prices of goods. Diamonds are now at an all time low because there is no need for multiple sets of God as you can continually repair using mending. Obviously there are flaws to the combat as there was in 1.8 however I would like to get the servers thoughts on a suggestion.

Would the server favor a reduction of the protection offered by protection enchants?  I believe that natural regen shouldn’t be able to keep a fighter alive in combat. Doesn’t make sense logically. If there is a way to increase the damage taken by a sword or axe against p4 to lets say .75 a heart instead of less than .5 hearts then natural regen would only postpone death instead of making a person immortal  This will need lots of testing however perfect 1.9 pvp exists without enchants. Once Prot and Sharpness gets involved the battles seem unrealistic and are pointless. What I am suggesting is bringing pvp back to the point where people can go after players out of vengeance. I miss the days when I could sneak up behind someone and hit them 5-10 times and kill them regardless of what they were wearing. 1.9 takes away from what was awesome about piratecraft (at least for me.)

No one in their right mind should be able to hold off 10 attackers. Anyone should be subject to death from a well organized team as well as one person should be able to kill 2-3 people if they time their attacks right and are strategic. Death is what makes an economy run in Piratecraft. If items are never lost then trade decreases. These changes will not affect deckies who just start as they will rely on un-enchanted gear and thus this change, if possible, will affect those who are OP.

The fundamentals of PVP in minecraft will never be perfect, however if there is a way to reduce the protection buffer given by prot enchants we can make a change into strategic/semi-realistic pvp.

Both pros/cons are welcome so please discuss below if this would be a welcomed change. I will also need to do some research into this to see if it is possible. If anyone has ways of doing this please comment below as well
Thanks everyone!
Chamberlain1