For anyone that finds this 6 month old thread that was dug up from the past, the outcome of this mega-thread was this:
When we finally get onto a host that can support more worlds, we will create a separate island-based world that will have No Map and No Tp, with trade routes and very limited Claiming for land (To stop people claiming near trade routes).
This is not in the near future as there are a few other projects I need to finish first on PirateCraft.