Ok, judging by the replies and the comments back that I have received, the initial idea sounds quite unnecessary, as many people (including GodsDead, thanks for replying by the way!) have detailed the ways that we are already helping new people on the server.
Due to this I feel that this plan is no longer needed, and I will now use the time to get back to work on my current building projects.
I would just like to say though, even if this is no longer going ahead, I want to encourage as many people as possible to be nice towards deckhands, and allow them to establish a base in peace so they can find stability before having to think about getting attacked.
Thanks so much to everyone for the amazing responses and feedback. Lord_Akley_VII
Piratecraft helper and the cooler half of Xenia