Pedantic pandering around what your interpretation of rules is patheitc and a waste of everyones time, especailly since you have not posted your chat histroy in public.

As also stated in the rules:

1. Staff decisions are final
   Do not contest or harass staff members over punishments

The full ruleset can be found at https://piratemc.com/information/rules/ which is linked in-game, which has more in depth information.

I have passed this post onto the moderation team to look at your chat histroy.

You may also want to read the rule:

1. Do not cause drama in public chats.
   Anyone participating but not limited to word-sniping, bickering, pettiness, will be muted/kicked on the spot. Insistence on participation in drama will result in a ban.

Closed.