This is a great idea 🙂

Maybe you guys could coordinate with those people who have started other resource pack projects (Nicky’s paintings and Bobbyjoefries’ sea shanties) to compile a single dedicated resource pack for the server?

Edit: Also it might be cool to replace some of the ambient minecraft sounds with pirate themed sounds i.e. Chickens make a seagull noise, wood creaking onboard ships (idek how you would implement that lol) and ship bells ringing etc.