Godsy, In my opinion removing the bottle plugin will make the line between rich and poor players even bigger. The well established players that have a ton of exp will have a huge advantage and make a ton of money.

Also, if we do remove the bottle plugin, the price for one stack of exp will skyrocket. It will probably go from 100 a stack to 300.

Edit: Good point Godsy. It is true that EXP bottles would be in limited stock, and removing /bottle would solve alot of problems.

Pro Tip: Incase /bottle does get removed, start farming and bottling exp. 😛

America, where the rich get richer and the poor get poorer!

But seriously, if you remove it All the op players with bottle O enchanting stashed will get even more stacked.

we can somewhat compare this to the god apple situation.

/bottle is it best it helps players that dont have villys that give xp out

I can only give you one side of the picture because I am still working hard to progress enough to compete with Veteran players. I only can give you the opinion of someone leveling, so I dont understand the other side of it. Basically are you trying to deplete thier stashes?

By this time most of the powerful people who this is set out to cap (I assume) already monopolies xp/god gear production. It would have a dent, but not much of an affect. And means that people like me who are trying to compete with the more experienced players are left struggling to get on par- without this ‘perk’.

This may not be relevant, but I think if we are trying to remove the division between the weak and the powerful is to remove God apples; the only real division.

God apples are no longer craftable (I don’t think) and that seriously hinders Pvp fights with veterens with huge supplies of god apples. Potions, normal golden apples and pretty much anything else are easy enough to make, but god apples are expensive and now near impossible to obtain. And people should be able to exchange their gapples for gold, gold that they would use for normal golden apples or potions.

Anyway, yea I don’t think you should remove the xp thingies, sorry.

i think it should be kept because one of the reasons it is to be removed is to try to balance the gameplay, people with more effecient villager farms can still get the stack or 2 bottles that they need for combat, and that leaves other players (the poorer or who hasnt built a villy farm yet) stuck with a dwindling supply of exp.

honestly i was split between the two choices, i like both of them, but without the bottle command, there is not much reason for a double exp weekend, except to fast rank up, which can be only used by some players.